Private School Parents Upset With Sachem's Bus Proposal

Reduction of mileage in budget-cutting plan could ostensively strand St. Anthony's students, among others.

Parents living in the Sachem School District who send their children to private school are upset to learn that the district is considering shrinking its transportation radius from 25 miles to 15.

Parents received a letter from the district's associate superintendent, Bruce Singer, stating that a possible referendum could be placed on the budget vote this year to roll back its busing to only the state required minimum of 15 miles.

The idea was put forth at the January 2 session of the Board of Education as a cost-saving measure against next year's $22 million shortfall. If the proposition is placed on the ballot and passes, Sachem will no longer provide transportation to students attending Our Lady of Mercy Academy in Syosset, St. Anthony's High School in Huntington and Bishop McGann-Mercy High School in Riverhead.

Now some of those parents are speaking out, and plan to attend tonight's board meeting to offer public comment.

"I realize the district is trying to do what's best for everybody, but is it really doing what's best for our kids that are in private school?" asked Frank Faber, whose daughter is a junior at St. Anthony's. "They already receive taxes from us and we don't ask for it back; the only thing we ask for is transportation."

Charlie Kutch has a daughter and son who both attend St. Anthony's. He also received the letter and stated in an email to Patch that he believes the district lacks foresight.

"The Sachem School District is again trying to target what they think is a group that they can walk over, namely students attending Catholic schools," Kutch stated. "Sachem would save a minimal amount of money in the short term but if they burden families enough and force us to move our kids to Sachem schools they will incur the cost of educating these students."

"I honestly think that in today's economy, there will be a lot parents that put their kids back in the public schools," Faber said in agreement with Kutch. The measure will affect approximately 80 students attending those schools. Faber said that in a conversation with Stephen Shadbolt, the transportation supervisor, it was estimated that transportation costs roughly $2,000 per student, which would translate to a savings of about $160,000 to the district.

However, Faber said it doesn't factor that Sachem receives roughly $21,000 in state aid for each student that lives in the district. Minus the $2,000 for transportation, $19,000 is free and clear if a student attends private school. That $19,000 would now be needed to educate the student if he or she returns to public school. 

"Now you're going to have to spend that on my kid," Faber said. "And you're going to have to raise all the taxes in the Sachem school district to make up for that."

Faber said his daughter is aware of the proposal and is very upset by it.

"My child chose to go to private school and we did whatever we could to make that happen," Faber said. "It's not that we're privileged. And it doesn't mean that we're better than anyone else. And every year that the school budget comes up I vote it up. I don't want any kids left behind as far as an education's concerned and all I'm asking for is transportation."

As for Kutch, he's imploring other impacted parent's to attend tonight's Board of Education meeting so their message can be heard by "fair-thinking residents."

The transportation savings is just one of many creative ways the board is attempting to reduce its deficit without significantly raising taxes. Other ideas include closing and consolidating school buildings, combining varsity programs between North and East and the sale of its administrative building at 245 Union Avenue in Holbrook. The board meetings are held every Wednesday at its annex building attached to Samoset Middle School at 7:30 p.m.

Kevin McGuire January 16, 2013 at 10:03 PM
This is one thing I never understood. Why is the district responsible for transporting students to private schools? With the current economic environment, how can we cut programs for our students while maintaining transportation costs for those that choose to go to private schools?
Brian January 17, 2013 at 04:09 AM
My parents fought the same thing with Three Village schools when I went to private school. Kevin, you asked why the district is responsible for transporting the students and I believe they are because these parents are still sending thousands of dollars in taxes to Sachem. At minimum, they should get a reduction of the amount of school taxes they pay (as should anyone else who is not directly benefiting from having children in school). Mr. Faber laid out the finances of this very well. Hard to argue his financial points. Sachem is getting $19k in state aid for each student in the district who does not attend Sachem.
Vincent Capodanno January 17, 2013 at 04:12 PM
You do realize that we pay exorbitantly high taxes, don't you? The cost of transporting private school students to and from school is trivial compared to the amount of money the state throws out the door on public education. $21,000/year is more than enough to educate a child, don't you think?
P Paul January 17, 2013 at 11:43 PM
Parents that send their children to private school still have to pay full school taxes. The least Sachem can do is to pay for travel to the school of their choice - just what all other students in the district receive.
Dog daze... January 22, 2013 at 02:21 PM
As parents of a child in a private school we pay the exact same school taxes that everyone else pays, we don't get a break on our taxes. That's many thousands of dollars a year that the school district gets for free. The least they can do for all that money is give the kids a bus ride to their school.
Stephanie January 24, 2013 at 06:49 PM
Because everyone is ENTITLED to a free appropriate public education...FAPE... transportation is the least they can do since the district is not even providing these students that. Since they prvide it for indistrict students they have to do the same for private. It is only fair!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something