Islip Comptroller: No Tax Increase Would Be Devastating

Facing $26 million deficit, the Islip Town Board will either need to make massive spending cuts or raise taxes.

How do you get out of a $26 million budget hole?

Not easily.

That’s what Islip Town officials are discovering as Town department heads outlined the effects of various potential cuts in the 2013 budget, including ones that could impact public safety, during a special meeting at Town Hall Thursday.

“There is no way I can manage this Town with any cuts appropriately and create safety for the residents of the Town of Islip,” said Department of Public Works Commissioner Tom Owens, who at one point was speaking so passionately on the issue that he was asked to slow down by the Town’s stenographer. 

Several department heads echoed the theme that cuts to the Town’s workforce, which would need to be slashed by 31 percent (or 224 workers out of 720) if the Town Board decides not to raise taxes, would have immediate negative impacts.

“We can’t do more with less, we can’t do the same with less,” said Planning Commissioner Dave Genaway, who added that a department budget cut of 10 percent would lead to delays in issuing various permits and stall several new technological projects meant to streamline the permit process. 

Owens said his department already has 100 less employees today than 10 years ago and the consequences of any cuts would include deteriorating roadways and dangerous circumstances when fallen trees are not quickly cleaned up. Snow plowing would also be cut to a minimum, with it taking days to clear roads after a storm. 

“To think about cutting this budget would be unconscionable,” Owens said.

When Owens heard that Town Supervisor Tom Croci wanted department heads to consider the impact of cuts of up to 50 percent, he said he had “many sleepless nights.”

“When you put your child on the bus after a snow storm, you want to know that this department has made their journey safe,” Owens said.  “I cannot guarantee that with these proposed cuts and that is not acceptable.”

The other impacts of budget cuts?

Terry Hennessey, the acting commissioner of MacArthur Airport, said they would hurt the chances of the airport attracting a new airline, which Hennessey said is a top priority. 

All parks, beaches and recreation centers around Town could also be shuttered.

In the end, the Town faces the choice that every other municipality with a budget gap does: raise taxes, cut spending or some combination of both.

Supervisor Croci leads a Republican Town Board that was swept into power last year when Croci defeated Phil Nolan by just a few hundred votes. 

While campaigning, Croci said “taxes were out control,” but now he may be headed toward presenting a budget that pierces the state’s new tax cap.

From the start of the meeting, Croci made clear whom he blames for the current predicament the town finds itself in: Phil Nolan.

Croci questioned Town Comptroller Joseph Ludwig over how the 2012 budget was created. 

“For whatever reason, he chose to use that fund balance and have a zero percent tax increase for the 2012 budget,” Ludwig said of Nolan, referring to $18 million from the Town’s “rainy-day fund” in the current budget. 

Ludwig said he made clear to the Nolan that going with no tax increase in 2012 would be devastating in subsequent years. 

“No doubt that the board and community are aware that last year was an election year so we can only surmise as to why that was the case,” Croci said.

Nolan, reached by phone Friday, said he gave the Republicans a chance to make amendments to the 2012 budget after the election last fall, but they chose not to.

“I was prepared to work with them,” said Nolan, who said he had a record of cutting spending and called the Republicans “hypocrites” for implying he was wrong to not raise taxes this year. “They didn’t change a single word in that budget.”

“All they’ve done is create dozens and dozens of jobs for political friends,” said Nolan, who was appointed president of Suffolk Off-Track Betting Corp. (OTB) earlier this year. “They haven’t cut a damn thing.”

Moving ahead, the Town has until Sept. 30 to craft an official budget proposal.  There’s obviously still many difficult decisions to be made.

“The type of cut to get to a zero-percent tax increase would be devastating to the Town of Islip,” said Ludwig, adding that cuts to staff would be felt by the public.

“There’s nothing worse than seeing a cold, miserable December 28th day, cold rains, winds and seeing a line outside the Tax Receiver’s Office, but that is exactly what would happen." 

The Town Board meets again next Tuesday at 2 p.m. 

Ed Horcrantz September 22, 2012 at 05:36 PM
Tom Croci and his VERY WEALTHY Part Time Town Board members receive NYSHIP Empire Plan health insurance for free! Do you? They pay nothing for the policy that costs Islip town Residents $19,000 a year! John Cocrane owns his own business, so does Steve Flotteron, so does Anthony Sneph, so does Tom Croci and so does Trish Bergins husband Randy. Can the middle class struggling residents of Islip afford to pay these premiums?
dsprinks September 24, 2012 at 11:01 PM
No tax increase woul be devastating?? We are getting taxed righ off of Long Island and many young people just starting out can't even get started!! What will we do when there are no taxpayers left?? I wish my bosses would give me a raise every time I got into debt!! Enough already!! Make the cuts and balance the damned budget without hurting the taxpayers any more than we already are!!!
Greg Fischer September 26, 2012 at 03:19 PM
So how did Islip get to this point and what can they do to reverse the trend? (Hint: support my appeal the NYS's highest court to have LIPA Trustees elected --- and cut power costs thereafter.) Over 100 lawyers and 20 municipalities helped get the MTA tax repealed, why am I doing this battle alone? Other towns could get big increases too if we don't wake the politicians up, LIPA costs have 20 times the effect of the MTA tax so this is important!
Sidney Beane September 26, 2012 at 03:58 PM
New Parks, Recreation, and Cultural Affairs Commissioner Joseph Montuori Jr. claims he only makes $30k a year, while the man he replaced, Greg Dawson, bowed out at $103k a year. Pull the other one Joe! And what's really rich is that he has a personal secretary (who makes more than $30k a year) and a personal assistant (who I'm sure makes more than $30k a year). But taxes must be raised!
Joe public September 29, 2012 at 01:56 AM
Good job Tom everyone look at you bill goto your school board see what they make with the highest tax on your bill or go yell at a cop for makeing 130000 a year taxes were at .9% haven't been raised in 20 years and now there getting raised and your moveing get real cut back on schools or cops


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »